Nyquist Plot & Stability Theory

1. Introduction & Mathematical Foundation

The Nyquist Stability Criterion is a method used in control systems to determine closed-loop stability by analysing the open-loop frequency response. It is based on the Cauchy's Argument Principle, which relates the encirclements of a point in the complex plane to the number of poles and zeros enclosed by a contour.

Instead of directly calculating all the closed-loop poles from the characteristic equation \(1 + G(s)H(s) = 0\), the Nyquist method maps a contour from the s-plane onto the complex plane using the open-loop transfer function \(G(s)H(s)\). This mapped curve is known as the Nyquist plot.

The criterion allows engineers to determine whether a closed-loop system is stable without explicitly solving for all its closed-loop poles. It can also be used to evaluate relative stability through gain margin and phase margin.

2. The Nyquist D-Contour & Mapping

Constructing the D-Contour

The Nyquist contour is a closed path in the s-plane that encloses the entire Right Half-Plane (RHP). It is used to investigate whether the closed-loop system has poles in the RHP.

For a system with no open-loop poles on the imaginary axis, the contour consists of:

  • Imaginary Axis: A path travelling from \(-j\infty\) to \(+j\infty\) along the imaginary axis.
  • Large Semicircle: A semicircular path of infinite radius in the RHP, connecting \(+j\infty\) back to \(-j\infty\).

If open-loop poles lie on the imaginary axis, small semicircular indentations are introduced to avoid passing directly through those poles. These indentations must also be included when mapping the contour onto the complex plane.

The mapped contour is obtained by evaluating the open-loop transfer function \(G(s)H(s)\) along the entire Nyquist contour.

3. The Cauchy Principle & Stability Equation

The Encirclement Equation

According to the Cauchy's Argument Principle, mapping a closed contour through a complex function produces a curve whose net encirclements of the origin are related to the number of zeros and poles enclosed by the original contour.

For the Nyquist Stability Criterion, the critical point is shifted from the origin to \(-1+j0\), since the closed-loop characteristic equation is:

\[ 1 + G(s)H(s) = 0 \]

Using the convention that clockwise encirclements are positive, the Nyquist stability equation is:

\[ N = Z - P \] \[ Z = P + N \]

Where:

  • \(Z\) = Number of closed-loop poles in the RHP.
  • \(P\) = Number of open-loop poles in the RHP.
  • \(N\) = Net number of clockwise encirclements of the critical point \((-1+j0)\). Counter-clockwise encirclements are counted as negative values.

Stability Requirement: For the closed-loop system to be asymptotically stable, it must have no poles in the RHP, meaning \(Z=0\). Therefore:

\[ N = -P \]

This means the Nyquist plot must produce the required net counter-clockwise encirclements of \(-1+j0\) to compensate for any open-loop RHP poles.

Note: This sign convention uses clockwise encirclements as positive. Other textbooks may use the opposite convention, so the corresponding equation must be adjusted accordingly.

4. Interpreting the Critical Point (-1 + j0)

Why -1 + j0?

The closed-loop transfer function for a negative-feedback system is given by:

\[ T(s) = \frac{G(s)}{1 + G(s)H(s)} \]

The denominator determines the closed-loop characteristic equation. If:

\[ 1 + G(s)H(s) = 0 \] \[ G(s)H(s) = -1 \]

The open-loop transfer function reaches the critical point \(-1+j0\) in the complex plane. This corresponds to a magnitude of 1 (0 dB) and a phase angle of \(-180^\circ\) (or an equivalent odd multiple of \(180^\circ\)).

If the Nyquist plot passes exactly through this critical point at a finite frequency, the closed-loop characteristic equation has a root on the imaginary axis. This indicates a boundary of stability and may result in sustained oscillations.

Therefore, the position of the Nyquist plot relative to \(-1+j0\), together with the number of open-loop RHP poles, determines closed-loop stability.

5. Gain Margin (GM) and Phase Margin (PM)

Quantifying Relative Stability

Besides determining whether a system is stable or unstable, the Nyquist plot can also help evaluate relative stability. Gain margin and phase margin indicate how much additional gain or phase lag a system can tolerate before reaching the stability boundary.

  • Gain Margin (GM): Evaluated at the phase crossover frequency (\(\omega_{pc}\)), where the phase angle reaches \(-180^\circ\). It measures how much the open-loop gain can increase before the Nyquist plot reaches the critical point.
    \[ GM = \frac{1}{|G(j\omega_{pc})H(j\omega_{pc})|} \]

    Expressed in decibels:

    \[ GM_{dB} = -20\log_{10}(|G(j\omega_{pc})H(j\omega_{pc})|) \]
  • Phase Margin (PM): Evaluated at the gain crossover frequency (\(\omega_{gc}\)), where the magnitude of the open-loop frequency response is exactly 1 (0 dB). It measures the additional phase lag required to reach the \(-180^\circ\) phase boundary.
    \[ PM = 180^\circ + \angle G(j\omega_{gc})H(j\omega_{gc}) \]

A positive gain margin and phase margin generally indicate a stable system when the usual single-crossover assumptions apply. However, systems with multiple crossover frequencies or unusual pole configurations require careful interpretation.

6. Summary Checklist for System Stability